U.S.: Cuban authorities harass santeros

|

The U.S. government-financed Commission on International Religious Freedom earlier this month issued a report on Santería in Cuba. Kirsten Lavery, a supervisory policy analyst with the commission, wrote the report, shown below.

This factsheet highlights the Santería practice in Cuba, providing an overview of this tradition and detailing the religious freedom conditions of its practitioners. Santería is a syncretic religion based significantly in the traditions of the Yoruba and incorporating elements of Catholicism. Today, roughly 70 percent of Cubans observe one or more Santeria or other religious practices based in an African tradition. Elements of Santería and its African roots permeate Cuban culture, including by influencing Cuban art, food, music, and dance.

Kirsten Lavery

Many Cubans can openly and freely practice Santería, including when interwoven with Catholicism. However, some Santería practitioners and religious leaders, especially those who are part of unregistered and independent communities, have experienced ongoing violations of religious freedom, including harassment, detainment, and repeated attempts by the government to co-opt their religion. While this factsheet is focused on the Santería community, the Cuban government’s treatment of independent Santería practitioners and the impact of restrictive laws and policies on the Santería community’s enjoyment of the freedom of religion or belief is illustrative of broader religious freedom conditions in Cuba.

Background
Afro-Cuban religions have long been an integral part of Cuban society. Santería is a syncretic religion rooted in the religious practices of the Yoruba people, who were brought as slaves to Cuba from the Congo Basin and West Africa, that incorporates elements of Catholicism. In early times, Santería developed and was practiced in secret, as Catholicism was the only religion permitted on the island by the Spanish colonial government. African gods were syncretized with Catholic saints and the religion adopted some Catholic religious practices. Practice of Afro-Cuban religions remained illegal even a er the abolishment of slavery. Following the 1959 revolution, Santería continued to be practiced on the island, despite restrictions on religion. While these restrictions aimed to suppress all religions, the Cuban government particularly targeted Catholicism and Santería due to their importance to Cuban identity.
Today, Santería religious practices continue to be intermingled with Catholicism, with some interpretations requiring Catholic baptism for full initiation into the faith. Santería practitioners make physical offerings to saints or deities, known as orishas. Orishas typically have a Catholic counterpart. As one example, the Santería orisha Ochún is syncretized with the patron saint of Cuba, la Virgen de la Caridad del Cobre. While many Cubans blend the two religions, the Catholic Church does not officially recognize Santería as a religion. As the Santería faith developed in secret, the Santería community did not build houses of worship and instead operates through private homes with altars and informal societies. There is no centralized authority for the tradition.
Although there are no independent and authoritative sources for religious demography in Cuba, an estimated 70 percent of Cuba’s 11 million people perform some type of Santería or other Afro-Cuban practice. It is further estimated that 60 percent of Cubans self-identify as Catholic, and many self-identified Catholics incorporate Santería practices into their faith. ese synergies between Santería and Catholicism make determining the number of Santería practitioners particularly difficult.

Religious Freedom Violations
The Cuban government uses a system of laws and policies, surveillance, and harassment to control religious groups and undermine the freedom of religion or belief. Government authorities repressively enforce these restrictions to ensure tight control over religious leaders, members of religious communities, and others deemed threats to the Cuban government’s agenda due to their advocacy or support for religious freedom.
Many Cubans can freely and openly practice Santería and celebrate its influence on Cuban culture. For those who blend religions, there is also space for many to practice Catholicism. At the same time, independent Santería communities and practitioners whose beliefs and practices do not align with the Cuban government’s agenda experience ongoing religious freedom violations. While the underground nature of the faith makes it difficult to obtain comprehensive information on the religious freedom conditions of Cuba’s Santería community, this section provides an overview of ongoing or recent violations of the religious freedom of the independent Santería community and highlights representative examples of these violations based on available information.

Threat of Criminal Penalties due to Failure to Register
In Cuba, all religious groups are required to register with the Office of Religious Affairs (ORA), an entity within the Cuban Communist Party (CCP) operating out of the Ministry of Justice. Membership in an unregistered religious group is a crime. Given the omnipresent threat of criminal penalties, unregistered religious groups are particularly vulnerable and frequently subjected to harassment by the ORA and other government authorities in Cuba.
There are several distinct Santería communities on the island. One such group, the Yoruba Cultural Association of Cuba, is registered with the ORA and allegedly government-controlled. The Free Yoruba Association of Cuba (Asociación de Yorubas Libres de Cuba, or “Free Yorubas”) is an independent Santería community that was founded in 2012 by Santería practitioners who did not agree with the Yoruba Cultural Association. The Free Yorubas have refused to register with the ORA, not wanting to come under the influence of the Cuban government. The Free Yoruba’s refusal to register has led to sustained harassment of this religious community and its leaders.

Harassment and Detention of Santería Religious Leaders and Practitioners
Across Cuba, certain religious leaders are the target of government-sponsored harassment campaigns. This harassment extends to several Santería religious leaders and practitioners, particularly targeting members of the Free Yorubas. The Cuban government has accused this group of “destabilizing society” and subjected its leaders to arbitrary detentions and beatings, destruction of ceremonial objects, police monitoring, and searches-and- seizures without probable cause. The Free Yorubas have also reported surveillance by state authorities, raising particular concern that state officials allegedly have hacked their social media accounts and used them to spread smear campaigns. These allegations fall in line with the larger trend of Cuban state officials using social media to harass and defame religious leaders.
Some Santería leaders were pressured to support the new constitution during the reform process that led to Cuba’s April 2019 constitution. Religious leader and activist Alexei Mora Montalvo was arrested for collecting opinions on the draft constitution in November 2018.
As government authorities continued their harassment campaign against Montalvo and his family, Montalvo went on a 15-day hunger strike in February 2019. In August 2020, Montalvo was again arrested for protesting against the Cuban regime. Montalvo has been subject to a travel ban and not allowed by the state to leave the island since 2018.
In 2019, at least one Santería follower, 17-year old Dairon Hernández Pérez, was repeatedly harassed and pressured for refusing to enlist in the Cuban military based on his religious beliefs. Cuba’s new constitution, passed in April 2019, makes it illegal to invoke conscientious objection to mandatory military service. In March 2019, a Yoruba high priest, or babalawo, was detained, beaten, and taken to a remote location by a group of plain clothed paramilitary led by a military official.
According to reports, the harassment of Free Yorubas increased in February 2020 after members of the community challenged Caridad Diego, the head of the ORA, to a public debate on freedom of conscience. State security arrested and threatened several high ranking Free Yorubas, including Eliaisys Almeida Pavón, Donaida Pérez Paseiro, and Loreto Hernández García, in February and March 2020. According to Pérez, state officials declared that “there is only one god, Fidel Castro” and used an obscenity about God and the Orishas. In August 2020, a Free Yoruba priest, priestess, and other members of the community were violently summoned to the police station and threatened. In another incident, two members of the executive committee of the Free Yorubas were arrested, held overnight, and beaten in September 2020.

Government Co-opting of Santería
The Cuban government has frequently been accused of trying to co-opt Santería religious practice. This dynamic of co-optation and resistance has played out in tension over the Letter of the Year, which is an important annual prophecy in the Yoruba calendar that is issued by babalawos of different branches of Santería. The government-controlled Yoruba Cultural Association and the Miguel Febles Padrón Commission issue an annual Letter of the Year that is backed by the government and widely shared through government media. Their Letter of the Year has been disavowed by independent, unregistered groups, like the Free Yorubas. The Free Yorubas have stated that the babalawos who produce this letter lack the religious moral authority to do so. The group has also critiqued the predictions in the government-backed letter for being manipulated and used to push the Cuban government’s agenda, by including, for example, recommendations that call on Cubans to “not participate in any conspiracy.”
The condemnation of government-appropriated Santería practice, including the Letter of the Year, has led to increased harassment of Santería leaders. In January 2018, the Free Yorubas issued a statement challenging the legitimacy of the Letter of the Year. Soon after, Alexei Mora Montalvo was forcefully detained by police. During his detention, police pressured Montalvo to join the Yoruba Cultural Association of Cuba. Several other Santería religious leaders were detained in relation to their criticism of the prophecy that year. In another incident in 2019, state security officials detained a Santería leader and told him to “stop stealing the [Santería priests] from the revolution.” In 2020, there were reports that at least one member of the Free Yorubas received threats and was told to keep quiet at the start of the year.

Regulation of Meeting Houses
Santería practitioners have few religious buildings, as rituals and ceremonies typically take place in private homes outfitted with altars. During the coronavirus pandemic, some Santería practitioners have continued to hold intimate or individual home rituals. With access to the internet expanding in Cuba in recent years, others have started hosting virtual rituals on social media.
Homes that host Santería ceremonies operate within the broader restrictions on religious buildings in Cuba, where it is illegal to hold religious activities in buildings not dedicated for religious use. The Cuban government uses a 2005 law regulating meeting houses and house churches to impose complicated and repressive requirements on the private residences used as places of worship.
This law also mandates registration according to strict procedures and empowers authorities to supervise and control the religious activities in private residences. Unregistered religious groups cannot apply to legalize the buildings used for religious services and risk penalties for congregating in unauthorized buildings.
In addition to facing the risk of sanctions for worshiping in unregistered buildings as an unregistered religious community, members of the Free Yorubas, according to some reports, are intimidated during their religious services. As an example, a one city block radius around a meeting house is regularly surrounded by police cars during religious services.

Other Potential Restrictions on Religious Practice
As part of the Santería religion, some practitioners participate in animal sacrifices. These religious rituals have at times led to conflict between the religious community and Cuban state authorities. Following unprecedented protests and demands from animal rights activists, the Cuban government is in the process of passing a new animal welfare law. It remains unclear what restrictions, if any, this law will place on Santería religious rituals.

Conclusion
The Cuban government’s restrictions on religion impact all religious communities on the island, including Santería practitioners. While allowing many Cubans to observe Santería and other Afro-Cuban practices, the Cuban government, at the same time, violates the freedom of religion or belief of independent Santería communities in a range of ways, including ongoing harassment, attempts to co-opt the faith for political purposes, and restrictions on members’ ability to worship in meeting houses. Members of unregistered Santería communities, particularly the Free Yorubas, are particularly vulnerable and face ongoing threats of criminal sanctions. These violations are emblematic of the tactics used by the Cuban government to control faith and suppress independent religious communities.
USCIRF’s 2020 Annual Report provided several recommendations for the United States to support religious freedom in Cuba, including that the State Department maintain Cuba on its Special Watch List (SWL) for engaging in or tolerating severe violations of religious freedom pursuant to the International Religious Freedom Act (IRFA). Pursuant to this recommendation, on December 2, 2020, the State Department again placed Cuba on its SWL. The U.S. government must continue to promote religious freedom in Cuba and work to ensure that all religious and belief communities, including those who observe the Santería tradition, can freely practice their faith.

8 thoughts on “U.S.: Cuban authorities harass santeros”

  1. that is a ridiculous report and a way to justify the money spent
    you can say the santeria is very well suited to the control apparatus, people get entertained with magic solutions and distracted from any political activity and many Babalawos are under the control of the spying services, not because they are harassed , but because they receive protection in exchange, for example they don’t declare the high income they get from charging “el derecho” to “hacerse santos” paid “cash” to them.
    The other reality is that according to most Christian churches in the US this is not a religion, but some sort of a ritual, sect or a satanic cult and the cruelty of the animal sacrifice rituals is also a realty that went to the Supreme Court https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_of_the_Lukumi_Babalu_Aye_v._City_of_Hialeah and it is becoming an issue all over the place now within the U.S. https://www.newsweek.com/what-santeria-couple-accused-cruelty-animals-say-their-religion-misunderstood-850926
    The nature of voodo rituals is that you don’t need a church or place to gather, it survived the initial years of the revolution because of that , people were able to keep conducting their practices in private to later became in the special period in the 90s the most practiced religion in Cuba and the official state religious creed, if you want to call it that way.
    You also have to consider that is part of the mystic of the Revolution, “Fidel Castro , El Caballo dressing in white in a trip to el Congo”
    Stories of vodoo in the Sierra Maestra, Raul Castro is said to believe and practice it, all part of a the popular mystification of the “revolution” Raul in on of his first trip as “president” with the Santeras in Brazil. One of the favorite arguments in debates about the effectiveness of Santeria to convince others is that “el caballo Fidel” who was invincible had a good “job” done on him.
    It is also a reality that it became a huge business, hacerte “santo en Cuba” costs thousands of dollars in the $5000 – $10000 range, so the dollarization also touched the business of Santeria, paleros, babalaos (voodo priests) have one of the highest standards of living in Cuba without going to any school ( the vast majority are illiterate) or religious studies of any sort. Anybody could be santero , just declare yourself you are one and run it from inside your own house (they dont deal with zoning issues in Cuba) and you are running a very lucrative business , in Cuba they dont pay taxes, they dont declare it, they get paid cash. It also an international business with many tourists from around the world going to cuba to “hacerse santos” and pay the high fees for that. It went from surviving in the dark years of the Soviet Union, to being tolerated, to become the Communist’s Party official religion and part of their mechanism of control.
    But disagree completely with that assessment that they are harassed, the reality is that they collaborate voluntarily with the regime because no other political system will give them the privileges they have with the revolution, the support of the state and the security apparatus.
    Another aspect is that is well tolerated by the Catholic Church in Cuba because is the only way to show that is not in decline and fill the churches with people going to pray not Christ or the Catholic Saints, but to pray the Orishas . On December 17th every year many go to the Church of el Rincon to pray Babalú-Aye (from yoruba Obalúwayé) “syncretized” with Saint Lazarus, just to mention one.
    How much money was spent to write those paragraphs?
    One isolated event means nothing or means a lot knowing how the government of Cuba operates.

    Reply
  2. I should add the ramification of the desecration of graves and bones that generates a lot of black market business for the state workers of the state cemeteries in Cuba (all cemeteries in Cuba are run by the state enterprise “servicios comunales”). They believe that “haciendo trabajos con cráneos, hand bones” the voodoo work is more effective. Read this article: https://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation-world/world/americas/cuba/article80907242.html
    ““The price of the bones can vary. For example, a cranium can cost $80 to $103 (US DOLLARS). The rest of the bones cost less, but we have to keep in mind that whoever does the work also has to eat,” said the priest., who used to work for the government’s funeral services agency. During that time, he said, he knew of about 800 complaints for tomb desecrations.”
    The phenomenon is so spread across cemeteries in Cuba that families in Cuba now prefer throwing ashes into de sea. Fidel ashes are protected in Santa Ifigenia by the military.
    They believe that if the bones are from someone who was a celebrity or someone notorious or powerful in live the more effective el “trabajo”is. In Havana and Old Havana they will think the Eusebio Leal’s skeleton is a one of the best to go after, it sounds crazy , but this are real world conversation between babalaos in Cuba, just to mention one example.
    I strongly believe the US needs to engage with Cuba in all aspects with Cuba, isolation for more than 60 years will make the work of any future government very difficult this is not about a simple dictatorship , but a very social complex situation and allowing Americans from all walks of live to interact with Cubans inside the island is the only way to have a possitive impact in the events inside the island, because whatever it happens on a long island in the middle of the Caribbean only 90 miles away from the US will have an impact inside the US.
    It is easy to overthrow a government, but in the case of Cuba what do you replace it with? The very next day tip to tip the island becomes a drug cartel, the conditions are there. So a peaceful transition is the best option for the US, it might not sound nice to many Cuban exiles , but the only way is the help those in power in Cuba, the new generation to make the necessary changes in a controlled environment with the best interests of the United States at the center. It can be done and it only takes good negotiators with the power of convincing others and understanding a unique multidimensional phenomenon like Cuba and putting the Miami politicians in Miami and the “democrat” Menendez aside. Miami’s Cuban Extreme Right lead by Rubio and company all supported Trump regardless when as Cubans they should have known better that a Castro looks like, they preferred to side with the American Castro. All Menendez did for the democrats in the last elections was a shy letter in Univision, when he knew that a well orchestrated Russian Style disinformation campaign was labeling democrats Biden and Harris as communists , Menendez did nothing about, he was Pro Trump as well to keep the show alive and keep getting reelected they had to reinvent the new Cuba right bribing the Santero Generation
    From January 21, 2021 : https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/11/us/florida-graves-theft-arrests.html
    “Two men were arrested and accused of stealing the remains of military veterans from a Central Florida cemetery last month, in order to use them in religious practices, the authorities said.”
    In the US this is bigger problem because most cemeteries are not monumental cemeteries like Cuba and it is easier to still the skulls and other pieces. It is spread all over the US with arrivals of Cubans and more recent arrivals the more of a problem it becomes.
    Even Marco Rubio who has been courting the evangelicals from his twitter account (sacred Pastor Rubio realized Trump won with the support of the evangelicals) is now a supporter of this rituals through the leader of his disinformation human troll farm team in Miami : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DcVYh44pucA and here https://www.rubio.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2020/12/rubio-habla-con-alex-otaola and even the evangelicals Trump and Diaz-Balart here embrace the Santero generation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7rdRyLCxMxM
    Everywhere there are Cubans in the US, any Cuban from any wave, but specially the Santero generation you can bet cemeteries have been desecrated and depending of the size of the Santero generation in each area in the hundreds at a minimum.

    Reply
    • Wow, I can see why people would prefer spreading their loved ones’ ashes at sea. Just imagine hearing that the bones of one of your loved ones are on sale. That would be awful!

      Reply
  3. Sorry about any typos I send the comments quick without time to review hope they are well understood, like on here:
    “In the US this is a bigger problem because most cemeteries are not monumental cemeteries like Cuba and it is easier to still the skulls and other pieces”. I meant “to steal”.
    That’s the real Cuba that has been cooking for while that only a totalitarian state can control the way it does and one of the many reasons the US needs to engage and start working with Cubans at all levels including those in power to a step by step solution and peaceful transition and transformation of Cuba.
    Isolation has proven counterproductive at all levels.

    Reply
  4. Add AT&T Copper Wire Theft Scheme to the list, they love underground in Miami.
    https://www.nbcmiami.com/news/local/5-arrested-in-att-copper-wire-theft-scheme-in-homestead/2394549/
    Miami is paying the consequences of what Rubio’s Miami is causing in Cuba with the embargo and the isolation. For Rubio, if they do the same in Cuba they are freedom fighters. What goes around comes around.
    No problem, Marco Rubio and Bod Menendez will ask the Biden Administration to pardon the Copper Cuban Five, they are loyal Trump supporters, they went to all the Trump rallies and caravans organized by the Rubio disinformation network of Cuban trolls in Miami and the Grant recipients and they deserve the same pardon that Dr. Melgen got from Trump at the request of Rubio-Menendez-Balart-Gimenez-Salazar “Dr. Salomon Melgen received a prison sentence of 17 years for stealing $73 million in one of the largest-ever Medicare fraud cases” the copper stealing is pennies in comparison and more importantly not a crime if committed by anti communist loyal Trump-Rubio-Menendez supporters in Miami.

    Reply
  5. Ms Lavery is a paid coup monger seems. That ORA (is it office of religious or regional affairs?) part was icing on the cake.

    Thanks for this Tracey!

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Marco Antonio Cancel reply